Skip to content

Early Career Scholars in the Theological Disciplines

Early Career Scholars in the Theological Disciplines: Old Testament Colloquium, Part 2

When: June 10, 2021, 1:45 pm - Thursday

Where: Ezell 211

Session 4

Session Abstract

The Colloquium this year is focusing on dissertation chapters from the student members. The Colloquium aims to foster interaction between current Ph.D. students and scholars affiliated with the conference. In Part 2 of the Colloquium, Ryan Replogle will present a portion of his dissertation, which focuses on cognitive perspectives of divine retribution in the Hebrew Bible. There will be three responses to Ryan’s dissertation section, followed by ample time for open discussion.


Paper Abstract

Ryan Replogle, Hebrew Union College, “The Perception of Divine Retribution in the Hebrew Bible”

This paper analyzes the belief of divine retribution in the Hebrew Bible from a cognitive-psychological lens. This belief, where divine power(s) reward the righteous and punish the wicked, was ubiquitous in the ANE. Yet, several passages from Psalms and the Wisdom Literature attest to doubt about the concept. I argue that these doubts resulted from inherent cognitive instability in how the belief would have been maintained: only ‘wickedness’ could be confirmed via the experience of calamity, whereas the absence of calamity hardly confirmed ‘righteousness.’ This imbalance thus periodically led to a breakdown in the entire schema.


Kipp Swinney, Baylor University, Convener

  • Ryan Replogle, Hebrew Union, "The Perception of Divine Retribution in the Hebrew Bible"
  • Daniel Oden, Harding University, Respondent
  • Melinda (Mindi) Thompson, Abilene Christian University, Respondent
  • Clay Smith, Baylor University, Respondent

2023 CSC Info Coming Soon

1 / 5

James Cone with conferee at the CSC in 2017

2 / 5

Pulitzer Prize winner Marilynne Robinson delivering the CSC plenary address

3 / 5

Francis Collins, director of the National Institutes of Health (NIH), delivering the CSC plenary address.

4 / 5

US Poet Laureate Tracy K. Smith delivering the CSC plenary address

5 / 5

David Brooks engaging conferees during breakfast at the CSC

We Mourn the Passing of Jan Randolph

July 31, 2022

We mourn the passing of Jan Randolph and grieve with her husband, Bob. For almost forty years Jan Randolph mentored scores of students and h...

National Stage, the CSC and a Quilt (and some answers about CALC)

May 17, 2022

On the evening of May 23 Dr. Catherine Meeks and David Brooks, together at the National Cathedral in Washington D.C., will address the topic...

Table Fellowship for the CSC Family of Scholars

May 17, 2022

The CSC is a “family of scholars” that honors the highest level of academic achievement and enjoys collegial company. Scholars f...

Site Designed and Developed by 5by5 - A Change Agency